Decision GuideRepair or Replace?
Age, shingles, decking, leaks and layers: the five things I check before telling anyone their roof has more life in it, or doesn't.
Pacific Northwest rain, moss, steep pitches, and freeze-thaw cycles require honest answers. No sales pitches, no fear tactics — just practical lessons from the field.
Decision GuideAge, shingles, decking, leaks and layers: the five things I check before telling anyone their roof has more life in it, or doesn't.
Bids & QuotesTwo bids for the same roof can be thousands of dollars apart. Here's how to tell whether they're even pricing the same job.
Materials GuideAsphalt, metal, cedar and composite: what actually holds up to Northwest rain, moss and wind, and what each one asks of you.
MaintenanceMoss is the Northwest roof's slow enemy. Here's how to get it off without damaging the shingles, and how to keep it from coming back.
Repairs & LeaksMost roof leaks start in a handful of predictable places. Here's where to look, what you can check yourself, and when to call someone.
WarrantiesTwo warranties, a lot of fine print. Here's what's really covered, what voids coverage, and what to get in writing before you sign.
VentilationIn our climate, one of the biggest threats to a roof comes from underneath. Here's how attic ventilation works and how to tell if yours is falling short.
From JustinI'm reading a roof before I ever climb a ladder. Here are the spots I check first, and what each one tells me.
A lower bid usually means a smaller scope, not a better deal. Line up the scope before you compare the price.
| Line Item | Contractor A (Lowball) | Contractor B (Standard) | Contractor C (PNW Spec) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Estimated Cost | Lowest | Middle | Highest |
| Underlayment | Standard 15# Organic Felt (tears easily) | Woven Synthetic Membrane | Breathable High-Temp Synthetic + Self-adhered valleys |
| Eave Ice & Water Shield | None (skipped to cut price) | 3 ft single course at gutter | 6 ft double course + all sidewalls |
| Drip Edge Flashing | Reused old bent metal | New 2x2 pre-painted aluminum | Heavy gauge galvanized T-style with kickout |
| Pipe Boots & Vents | Cheap neoprene rubber boots (dry-rot in 5 yrs) | Standard lead or plastic collars | Lifetime silicone flashing with retro collars |
| True Manufacturer Warranty | Materials only, prorated | Standard manufacturer warranty | Enhanced manufacturer system warranty, registered |
Example for illustration. Actual specs and prices vary by home and contractor.
Print this out or keep it on your phone before any salesperson sits at your kitchen table.