Choosing Roofing Materials for Northwest Weather
Asphalt, metal, cedar and composite: what actually holds up to Northwest rain, moss and wind, and what each one asks of you.
Justin Shirley · CEO, State Roofing & Exteriors · President, RCAW
8 min read
Published

The short version
- ✓Architectural asphalt shingles are the most common choice here: the lowest upfront cost, and realistically 18–25 years.
- ✓Standing seam metal costs more upfront, but it sheds rain and moss well and lasts far longer when it's flashed right.
- ✓Cedar shakes look the part, but they need steady maintenance in our climate.
- ✓Whatever you choose, the underlayment, flashing and ventilation matter as much as the surface.
The right roof for a sunny lot isn't automatically the right roof for a house tucked under Douglas firs, or one east of the mountains. Start with what your roof is up against, then pick the material.
What Northwest roofs are up against
- ✓Long wet seasons. Months of rain mean the roof rarely dries out completely.
- ✓Shade and moss. Trees and north-facing slopes grow moss that holds water and lifts shingle edges.
- ✓Wind. Coastal and Puget Sound windstorms test how well a roof is fastened and sealed.
- ✓East of the Cascades. Hotter summers, colder winters, snow loads and wildfire risk.
- ✓Snow and ice. At elevation, heat escaping into the roof can cause ice dams at the eaves.
Architectural asphalt shingles
The most common roof in the Northwest, and for good reason: the lowest upfront cost of the main options, lots of colors, and simple repairs.
The trade-off is lifespan. Moss and shade wear them down, so plan on 18 to 25 years here, not the number on the package.
What to look for: a high wind rating, algae-resistant granules (they help with black streaks, not moss), and installation as a full manufacturer system so the warranty holds.
Best for: most homes, and owners planning to stay 10 to 20 years.
Standing seam metal
Metal sheds rain and snow fast, and moss has a hard time getting established on it. Installed well, it often lasts 40 years or more, weighs less than most other options and resists fire.
The trade-offs: a significantly higher upfront cost, and it needs an installer who specializes in it. The flashing at walls, chimneys and valleys makes or breaks a metal roof.
Hidden-fastener panels are worth asking about. Exposed-fastener panels cost less, but their screws and rubber washers need checking and replacing over the life of the roof.
Best for: long-term owners, steep or shaded roofs, snow country and wildfire areas.
Cedar shakes and shingles
Nothing looks more like the Northwest. But in our wet climate, cedar needs regular cleaning and treatment to slow moss, rot and splitting.
Untreated wood is also a fire concern, and some wildfire-prone areas restrict it. Expect more maintenance, and often a higher price, than asphalt.
Best for: owners who want the look and will keep up with the care, and some historic homes.
Composite and synthetic shake or slate
These give you the look of shake or slate without the wood maintenance. Most resist rot and moss, and many carry strong fire and impact ratings, depending on the product.
They cost more than asphalt, and quality varies between manufacturers, so the product's track record matters. Fewer crews install them.
Best for: owners who want a shake or slate look without the upkeep.
Low-slope sections need their own system
Porch roofs, dormers and additions with very little pitch shouldn't get shingles. Shingles need enough slope to shed water, and manufacturers set a minimum.
Low-slope areas need a membrane roof instead, such as TPO, PVC or modified bitumen. Make sure your estimate prices those sections separately and correctly.
The parts you don't see matter just as much
- ✓Underlayment: synthetic across the deck, plus ice-and-water membrane in valleys and around penetrations.
- ✓Flashing: new metal at walls, chimneys, skylights and valleys.
- ✓Ventilation: balanced intake and exhaust to keep the attic dry.
- ✓A premium surface over a poor system still fails early.
Side by side
| Material | Upfront cost | Realistic life in the Northwest | Upkeep | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Architectural asphalt | Lowest | 18–25 years | Moss control, gutter cleaning | Most homes |
| Standing seam metal | Highest | Often 40+ years when well installed | Low | Long-term owners; steep, shaded or snowy roofs |
| Cedar shake | Mid to high | Varies widely with upkeep | High | Owners who want the look and keep up the care |
| Composite shake or slate | Mid to high | Depends on the product; check the manufacturer | Low | Shake or slate look without wood upkeep |
Justin's rule of thumb
Pick the installer before you fall in love with a material. A great product installed badly is a bad roof.
Comparing bids for different materials?
The free Roof Estimate Checklist keeps them side by side.
Common questions
What is the best roofing material for the Pacific Northwest?
It depends on your budget and how long you'll stay. Architectural asphalt has the lowest upfront cost; standing seam metal costs more but sheds rain and moss well and often lasts 40 years or more when installed well.
Do algae-resistant shingles prevent moss?
No. Algae-resistant granules help with black streaks caused by algae, not with moss.
Can a low-slope roof section have shingles?
No. Shingles need enough slope to shed water, so low-slope sections like porch roofs need a membrane roof such as TPO, PVC or modified bitumen.

Justin Shirley
Justin Shirley is CEO of State Roofing & Exteriors and President of the Roofing Contractors Association of Washington (RCAW).
More about Justin